A Wider Net

This 52″ Multitouch screen that LG/Philips showcased at CES appears at first to trump the Microsoft Surface product, at least in terms of a multitouch interactive display device. Surface is a coffee table, whereas this is a wall-mount display. Surface is, again, a coffee table, and this is a flat panel display. They both offer multi-touch. But when you watch the video below you notice several big differences. The surface interface demos have been optimized for intuitive behavior. If you place your hand on an image and drag your hand it moves the image with your hand. In the LG/Philips demo, the hand movements of the presenter and the google earth images on display are not intuitively connected. Also, he regularly struggles with the interface which is the exact opposite experience of Surface. Frankly, I could have brought up the images he requested far faster with a traditional mouse and keyboard, so what’s the point?

The Surface team has been very careful to make sure they design applications that use the technology effectively and appropriately. They step back and ask themselves “could I do this as well or better with a mouse and keyboard or a traditional touch screen?” and “Am I adding value or adding to the experience with this technology”.

The best part of seeing this video is the fact that other companies are getting inspired to join the party. Multi-touch interfaces are a big part of our man-machine interface future, and like the iPhone, Surface is creative very positive activity in the research labs of their competitors. Now I think they need to pick up the pace!

Thanks again, Engadget.